From spousal maintenance and earning capacity assessments to neurodivergence, reasonable workplace adjustments, caring responsibilities and university transitions, vocational expertise has a much wider role in legal proceedings than many solicitors realise.
When solicitors think of vocational rehabilitation, they often think of returning an injured client to work. But what about a parent who has spent 20 years raising children and is now facing divorce? A parent whose child has complex health needs and requires ongoing support? A neurodivergent professional whose employment prospects are being underestimated? Or a young person with a visual impairment trying to identify a realistic university or career pathway?
These are just some of the circumstances in which vocational expertise may provide valuable insight.
Vocational rehabilitation is not simply about finding employment. It is about understanding an individual's abilities, limitations, transferable skills, aspirations and future potential — and assessing what may realistically be achievable within their circumstances.
For solicitors working across family law, divorce, financial remedies, personal injury, clinical negligence and employment litigation, specialist vocational evidence can help answer questions that medical, financial and other professional reports may not fully address.
Divorce and Financial Remedies: What Is Someone Really Capable of Earning?
Earning capacity can become a significant area of disagreement in divorce proceedings.
One spouse may argue that their former partner is capable of returning to work and becoming financially independent. The other may have spent decades outside the workforce raising children, supporting a partner's career or providing unpaid care.
But how do you establish what is genuinely realistic?
Under Section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, the court considers several factors when determining financial provision, including each party's current and foreseeable income, earning capacity, financial needs and responsibilities.
A vocational expert can help provide an objective assessment of an individual's realistic employment and earning prospects.
This may involve considering:
- Qualifications, previous employment and transferable skills.
- The impact of a prolonged career break.
- Whether existing qualifications remain relevant.
- The realistic availability of suitable employment.
- Retraining requirements, associated costs and timescales.
- Physical or mental health conditions affecting employability.
- Caring responsibilities and their practical impact.
- Potential earning capacity over the short, medium and longer term.
Consider this scenario:
A couple divorces after 25 years of marriage. One spouse has an established career and substantial earnings. The other left employment 18 years ago to raise their children.
The financially stronger spouse argues that their former partner could earn £35,000 annually.
But is that realistic?
What qualifications do they hold? Are their skills current? Would retraining be necessary? What could they reasonably earn immediately, in two years, or in five?
A vocational assessment can help move the discussion beyond assumptions and provide evidence-based opinions on realistic earning potential.
This can be particularly relevant when solicitors are considering spousal maintenance, the duration of financial support, or the feasibility of future financial independence.
When Children Have Additional Health or Care Needs: The Impact on Parental Earning Capacity
An often-overlooked consideration in financial remedy proceedings is the impact of a child's disability, chronic illness, neurodivergence or additional care needs on a parent's capacity to work.
Traditional assumptions about returning to employment as children become older may not reflect the realities of families where additional parental support remains essential.
Consider a parent whose 14-year-old child has complex medical needs.
Although the child attends school, they may require frequent hospital appointments, therapy sessions, medication management or specialist supervision. Their condition may fluctuate, resulting in unpredictable school absences or periods when the parent must provide additional care at home.
Alternatively, a child with autism, ADHD or other additional needs may require considerable support with education, transitions, emotional regulation or daily activities.
The parent may have the qualifications and experience to return to full-time employment. But can they realistically sustain it?
A vocational assessment may consider:
- The nature and frequency of the child's additional support requirements.
- How caring responsibilities affect the parent's availability for work, training or study.
- The practical impact of appointments, emergencies and unpredictable absences.
- Whether suitable employment offers sufficient flexibility.
- The availability and reliability of alternative care arrangements.
- Whether retraining or professional development is achievable alongside caring responsibilities.
- The difference between potential full-time earnings and realistically sustainable working hours.
- How future changes in the child's needs may affect the parent's longer-term earning capacity.
The distinction is important: having the skills to undertake a job does not necessarily mean having the practical circumstances to sustain that employment.
For example, a parent may be capable of earning £40,000 in a full-time professional position. However, if their child's needs restrict them to flexible part-time employment, their realistic earning capacity may be substantially different.
Equally, a child's needs should not automatically be treated as preventing parental employment. The relevant question is how those responsibilities interact with the parent's skills, available support, working arrangements and genuine employment opportunities.
Specialist vocational evidence can help solicitors explore these questions objectively rather than relying on assumptions about the availability of childcare, the age of the children or the parent's theoretical earning potential.
This may be particularly valuable when considering spousal maintenance, financial independence and the timescales within which a parent might reasonably be expected to increase their earnings.
Spousal Maintenance: When Could Financial Independence Realistically Be Achieved?
A person's theoretical ability to work is not the same as their practical ability to become financially independent.
In financial remedy proceedings, the question may not simply be whether someone could work, but what steps, resources and time they would reasonably require to increase their earning capacity.
For example, a 52-year-old individual who has been financially dependent on their spouse for many years may have the motivation to re-enter employment but lack recent experience, recognised qualifications or confidence.
Another individual may have strong professional qualifications but be balancing their own health condition with ongoing caring responsibilities for a disabled child.
A vocational expert may be able to assess realistic employment options, identify necessary training and estimate the timescales involved in developing earning potential.
Such evidence may help solicitors and the court examine whether proposed expectations around future earnings are achievable.
It can also identify situations where significant barriers to employment are unlikely to be resolved through retraining alone.
Earning capacity should be assessed against realistic opportunities and individual circumstances, not simply hypothetical salaries.
Family Proceedings: When a Parent's Future Circumstances Matter
Vocational assessments may also have relevance in certain family proceedings, particularly where a parent's capacity to achieve financial stability or develop greater independence forms part of a wider assessment.
For example, a parent may be recovering from a significant illness, managing a disability, returning to education after a prolonged absence, or rebuilding their circumstances following domestic abuse.
They may also be supporting a child with complex physical, emotional or developmental needs.
Where relevant to the issues before the court, vocational input may help clarify:
- Realistic training or employment opportunities.
- Barriers to achieving financial independence.
- The effect of disability or caring commitments on vocational options.
- The support and timescales required to develop sustainable earning capacity.
- Whether proposed expectations are achievable within an individual's circumstances.
A vocational assessment does not replace a parenting assessment, social work opinion, psychological assessment or judicial determination.
However, where vocational capacity is a specific and necessary issue, specialist input may provide an additional perspective that other professional assessments are not designed to offer.
Young People and the Transition to Adulthood: Choosing a Future That Fits
Vocational expertise is not exclusively relevant to adults who have already entered the workforce.
For young people with disabilities, acquired injuries, neurodivergence, visual impairments or complex health needs, making decisions about higher education and future independence can be particularly challenging.
Consider a 17-year-old who has sustained a brain injury and is preparing to apply to university.
They may have strong academic results, but questions remain about fatigue, concentration, executive functioning, physical accessibility and the demands of independent study.
Or consider a young person with a significant visual impairment who is academically capable but uncertain which degree or professional pathway would offer the greatest opportunities.
Which degree pathway is realistic? What learning environment would best suit their needs? Would a full-time programme be sustainable? Could assistive technology or reasonable adjustments make a preferred pathway achievable?
A vocational consultant may help examine:
- Individual interests, strengths, aptitudes and aspirations.
- The suitability of potential degree subjects and vocational pathways.
- Entry requirements and realistic routes into higher education.
- How disability, visual impairment or injury may affect particular study and career choices.
- The availability of assistive technology and accessible learning environments.
- The practical demands of different professions.
- Whether alternative pathways, including part-time study or professional qualifications, could be appropriate.
- The relationship between educational choices and future earning potential.
For solicitors representing children and young people following serious injury, this type of assessment can also help inform discussions about future educational and vocational needs.
It is not about limiting ambition. It is about identifying achievable pathways, removing unnecessary barriers and understanding the support that may be required.
A young person's future should not be defined solely by their diagnosis or injury. Their abilities, interests and aspirations deserve equal consideration.
Neurodivergence in the Workplace: Are We Underestimating Earning Potential?
Neurodivergence is an increasingly important consideration in employment, disability discrimination and vocational assessment.
Autism, ADHD, dyslexia and dyspraxia can influence how individuals process information, communicate, organise tasks or respond to different workplace environments.
Yet neurodivergence does not automatically indicate reduced ability or limited earning potential.
A person may possess exceptional technical skills, specialist knowledge or professional qualifications while experiencing barriers associated with conventional working practices.
For example, an autistic professional may thrive in a highly skilled analytical role but find an open-plan office, unpredictable meetings or ambiguous instructions difficult to manage.
An employee with ADHD may perform exceptionally well in a dynamic role but benefit from clearer task prioritisation, written instructions or flexibility in how work is organised.
The question for a vocational expert is not simply whether an individual has a diagnosis.
It is whether the barriers they experience genuinely restrict their vocational capacity — and how that capacity might change when appropriate support is available.
This distinction may be particularly important when assessing:
- Whether an individual could reasonably sustain their existing occupation.
- The effect of workplace barriers on performance, progression or job retention.
- Whether alternative working arrangements could improve employment sustainability.
- The availability of suitable roles within the wider labour market.
- Whether retraining or a career change is genuinely necessary.
- Future earning potential with and without appropriate workplace support.
In employment litigation, this analysis may help inform questions about future loss of earnings, alternative employment opportunities and the vocational consequences of workplace difficulties.
In divorce or financial remedy proceedings, it may also be relevant where an individual's neurodivergence is being used to support assumptions about either their inability to work or their presumed capacity to earn a particular salary.
Both assumptions require careful examination.
Reasonable Adjustments: What Does 'Reasonable' Actually Mean?
The phrase reasonable adjustments is frequently used in discussions about disability and employment.
But what does it mean in practice?
Under the Equality Act 2010, employers have a duty to make reasonable adjustments where a disabled worker or applicant would otherwise experience a substantial disadvantage.
What is considered reasonable depends on the individual circumstances, including the effectiveness, practicality and cost of the proposed adjustment and the employer's resources.
Importantly, reasonable adjustments do not always involve expensive equipment, extensive workplace alterations or significant financial investment.
Many effective adjustments cost little or nothing.
Examples may include:
- Providing written instructions rather than relying solely on verbal communication.
- Offering a quieter working area or reducing unnecessary sensory distractions.
- Allowing greater flexibility around start and finish times.
- Providing advance notice of meetings or changes to routines.
- Agreeing clear priorities, deadlines and structured feedback.
- Allowing additional processing time where appropriate.
- Adjusting communication methods to suit individual needs.
- Introducing flexible breaks or a phased return to work.
- Making existing documents accessible to screen-reading software.
- Allowing home or hybrid working where suitable for the role.
For individuals with visual impairments, adjustments might involve accessible electronic documents, screen magnification, screen-reader compatibility, improved lighting or specialist equipment.
Some adjustments may have a financial cost, while others require little more than a change in working practices or communication.
Not every adjustment will be reasonable in every workplace, and the appropriate solution must be considered individually.
Translating Reasonable Adjustments into Vocational Expert Evidence
This is where the role of vocational expertise becomes particularly valuable.
A medical expert may identify a disability or functional difficulty. An occupational health or workplace assessment may recommend specific adjustments.
A vocational expert can then consider what these findings mean for employability, job sustainability, access to suitable occupations and future earning capacity.
For example, imagine an experienced professional with ADHD who leaves employment after struggling with the organisation's working environment.
Without further investigation, it may be assumed that their condition substantially limits their ability to undertake similar work.
However, what if their difficulties could have been reduced through written task instructions, structured supervision and a quieter working environment?
Would they have been able to remain in their previous role? Could they secure comparable employment elsewhere? Would their earning potential differ if suitable support were available?
A vocational expert may examine:
- The individual's qualifications, skills, strengths and functional abilities.
- The practical demands of their occupation.
- The barriers encountered in the previous workplace.
- The types of adjustments that may make employment more sustainable.
- Whether comparable employers or alternative roles could realistically accommodate those needs.
- The availability and potential cost of relevant support.
- The likely impact of adjustments on job retention, career progression and earning capacity.
Where appropriate, the expert may draw on occupational health, occupational therapy, medical or specialist workplace evidence.
The expert's role is not to determine whether an employer has breached the Equality Act. That is a legal question.
Instead, independent vocational evidence can help establish the practical consequences of workplace barriers and assess how realistic employment prospects may differ with appropriate adjustments.
The central question becomes: is the individual's earning capacity genuinely limited by their disability, or are there workplace barriers that could reasonably be reduced or removed?
That distinction can be highly relevant when considering future losses, mitigation of loss, employability and sustainable career opportunities.
For some individuals, additional support may also be available through Access to Work, which can help with eligible disability-related employment support beyond an employer's reasonable adjustment responsibilities.
Understanding these possibilities can prevent vocational assessments from unnecessarily underestimating an individual's abilities or future opportunities.
Visual Impairments: Understanding Functional Ability Beyond the Diagnosis
Visual impairment provides another important example of why vocational capacity should not be determined by diagnosis alone.
Two individuals with similar clinical descriptions of sight loss may have very different functional abilities, skills, support needs and vocational opportunities.
An individual with a visual impairment may be entirely capable of continuing in a professional occupation with appropriate adaptations, while another may require substantial retraining or assistance to explore alternative employment.
Relevant considerations can include:
- The functional impact of visual impairment on specific occupational tasks.
- The accessibility of workplace environments and equipment.
- The availability of assistive technologies, including screen readers and magnification software.
- Travel requirements and the practical demands of commuting.
- The accessibility of training, professional development and educational opportunities.
- Whether alternative working arrangements could support continued employment.
- The individual's previous experience, transferable skills and vocational aspirations.
For solicitors dealing with personal injury, clinical negligence or employment-related matters involving sight loss, vocational evidence can help examine the real-world consequences for employment, career progression and earning potential.
A diagnosis may explain the nature of an impairment, but it does not necessarily establish what a person can achieve professionally.
Understanding the interaction between the individual, their environment and the demands of employment is essential to establishing realistic vocational prospects.
Personal Injury and Clinical Negligence: The Career That Never Happened
Vocational expert evidence is often associated with assessing lost earnings following an established career.
But what happens when the injured person has never worked?
A teenager sustaining a catastrophic injury may have no employment history, no established salary and no defined career trajectory.
Yet the injury may significantly alter their future educational choices, employment opportunities and earning capacity.
In these circumstances, vocational assessment may help explore potential pre-injury pathways and compare them with realistic post-injury opportunities.
Relevant considerations may include academic attainment, interests, aptitudes, family and educational background, transferable abilities, medical evidence and labour market information.
For example:
A 16-year-old aspiring to enter a physically demanding profession sustains a life-changing spinal injury.
Although that career may no longer be practical, other professional pathways may remain available.
A vocational expert can help consider how different options compare, what qualifications might be required and how future earning potential may differ.
The assessment should also consider whether reasonable adjustments, assistive technology or alternative working arrangements could preserve opportunities that might otherwise be dismissed.
This can assist solicitors when considering loss of earning capacity, future vocational needs and rehabilitation planning.
It can also prevent assumptions that someone with a significant disability has no meaningful future employment prospects.
Disability, Chronic Illness and Fluctuating Conditions: Capacity Is Not Always Consistent
Some of the most complex vocational questions arise when an individual's abilities fluctuate.
People living with chronic illness, neurological conditions, persistent pain, mental health difficulties or fatigue-related conditions may be capable of undertaking certain activities but unable to sustain them consistently.
A medical report may describe symptoms, treatment and functional limitations. A vocational assessment addresses a different question:
What do those limitations mean in practical terms for sustainable employment and future earning capacity?
Someone may be physically capable of working for several hours on a good day but unable to maintain a conventional working pattern.
Another individual may have the cognitive ability to undertake a professional role but struggle with the pace, demands or environmental conditions associated with that profession.
Vocational expertise can help assess the interaction between functional ability, work demands, flexibility, skills and realistic opportunities.
This may include considering whether reasonable adjustments could improve sustainability or whether the underlying limitations remain significant despite appropriate support.
Such evidence can be relevant in clinical negligence, personal injury, employment-related disputes and financial remedy proceedings where earning capacity is contested.
It also helps distinguish between being capable of performing a task and being capable of sustaining paid employment over time.
Employment Disputes: Understanding Future Prospects Beyond the Previous Role
In employment disputes involving disability, discrimination or alleged loss of future earnings, the vocational questions may extend beyond whether someone could return to their previous position.
An individual's qualifications and experience may remain valuable even when their previous workplace, working conditions or role is no longer suitable.
A vocational assessment may help explore:
- Transferable skills and alternative occupational pathways.
- The availability of comparable employment.
- The impact of disability-related restrictions on realistic opportunities.
- The potential effect of reasonable adjustments on sustainable employment.
- The likely vocational consequences of a prolonged absence.
- Retraining requirements and timescales.
- Potential future earnings in alternative occupations.
This may be particularly relevant in cases involving neurodivergence, visual impairment or other conditions where workplace accessibility and support can have a substantial influence on employment outcomes.
Such opinions may assist where questions of employability, mitigation of loss or future earning capacity arise, subject to the relevant tribunal or court's rules on expert evidence.
Court of Protection and Deputyship: Looking Beyond Immediate Care Needs
For individuals living with acquired brain injuries, neurological disabilities or complex long-term conditions, support needs may extend far beyond care arrangements and medical treatment.
Questions about education, meaningful activity, vocational development and future independence may arise as part of wider planning.
For example, a young adult who sustained a serious brain injury may express an ambition to attend university, undertake training or explore a professional qualification.
Another individual with a visual impairment may wish to enter employment but require advice about accessible training pathways, workplace adaptations or assistive technology.
A vocational assessment may help evaluate realistic options, identify barriers and consider what support could be required.
For deputies and solicitors working with individuals who have complex needs, vocational input may help inform appropriate care and rehabilitation planning, financial forecasting and decisions about resources, where relevant and within the applicable legal framework.
The objective is not always paid employment.
Sometimes it is about establishing realistic opportunities for personal development, participation, independence and a sense of purpose.
Why the Right Vocational Evidence Matters
Legal professionals routinely instruct medical experts, psychologists, occupational therapists, care experts and financial specialists.
Each provides essential evidence within their own field.
However, there can be a gap between understanding an individual's diagnosis, understanding their financial circumstances and establishing what they may realistically achieve in the future.
That is where vocational expertise may add value.
A vocational expert considers how education, skills, experience, health, caring responsibilities, personal circumstances and labour market opportunities interact.
Their conclusions can help solicitors evaluate whether proposed employment pathways are realistic, whether adjustments could improve an individual's opportunities, whether retraining is feasible and whether assumptions about future earnings are supported by evidence.
Importantly, independent expert evidence and practical vocational rehabilitation are distinct services.
An independent expert provides impartial opinions within the scope of their expertise and instructions. A vocational rehabilitation consultant may instead work directly with an individual to develop and implement a vocational plan.
Recognising that distinction helps ensure the right professional is instructed for the right purpose.
When Should Solicitors Consider a Vocational Expert?
Vocational expertise may be worth considering when a case raises questions such as:
- Divorce: What could a spouse realistically earn after a 15-year career break?
- Financial remedies: How long might reasonable retraining take before earning capacity increases?
- Spousal maintenance: What evidence supports assumptions about future financial independence?
- Children with additional needs: How do a child's ongoing health conditions or disability-related care requirements affect a parent's capacity to work?
- Family proceedings: Are proposed expectations around a parent's vocational development realistic and relevant to the issues before the court?
- Neurodivergence: Could reasonable workplace adjustments enable an individual to sustain employment or progress professionally?
- Visual impairment: What employment opportunities remain realistic with appropriate accessibility measures and assistive technology?
- Clinical negligence: How might a delayed diagnosis affect someone's ability to enter or continue a chosen profession?
- Personal injury: What would a young person's likely vocational pathway have been without the injury?
- Young adults: Which degree, university environment or qualification route could best accommodate an individual's strengths and limitations?
- Disability disputes: What employment options are realistically sustainable given fluctuating functional capacity?
- Employment litigation: What alternative employment and earning opportunities may be available, and how might workplace adjustments influence those prospects?
- Court of Protection: What vocational opportunities could contribute to a person's longer-term rehabilitation and independence?
These are not questions that can always be answered by reviewing a medical report or obtaining a generic labour market salary.
They may require specialist analysis of the individual, their circumstances and the opportunities genuinely available to them.
Meet Our Specialists: Karen Elsmore and Maria Morris
At Circle Case Management, we recognise that vocational questions can involve much more than conventional employment and career planning.
Our team includes professionals with experience across vocational rehabilitation, occupational therapy, disability and complex rehabilitation.
Karen Elsmore – Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant and Expert Witness
Currently accepting new instructions across the UK
Karen provides specialist vocational rehabilitation consultancy and expert witness services.
Her vocational expertise can assist solicitors seeking a clearer understanding of an individual's abilities, employability, transferable skills, realistic vocational opportunities and future earning potential.
Her involvement can be considered across a broad range of instructions, including financial remedy proceedings, personal injury, clinical negligence, employment-related disputes and complex cases involving disability or disrupted educational and vocational pathways.
Whether the question concerns a spouse's realistic earning capacity, a young person's future educational and career opportunities, or the vocational impact of serious injury, Karen can discuss the scope and suitability of a proposed instruction.
Karen currently has capacity for new instructions nationwide.
Maria Morris – Senior Expert Witness and Vocational Rehabilitation Case Manager
Specialist expertise in visual impairments
Maria Morris is an experienced Occupational Therapist, Senior Expert Witness and Vocational Rehabilitation Case Manager at Circle Case Management, with specialist expertise in visual impairments.
Her background combines occupational therapy, rehabilitation and vocational understanding, providing valuable insight into the functional and practical consequences of disability.
Maria's specialist knowledge of visual impairment is particularly relevant when considering how sight loss can affect independence, everyday activities, accessibility and participation in work or education.
This includes understanding how environmental adaptations, assistive technology and appropriate support may influence an individual's functional abilities and opportunities.
Her experience is especially relevant in complex cases where visual impairment, disability or rehabilitation needs interact with vocational goals and longer-term independence.
For solicitors dealing with complex disability-related cases, her occupational therapy and rehabilitation perspective can complement the work of vocational experts and other specialists, helping to build a more comprehensive understanding of an individual's circumstances.
Bringing the Right Expertise Together
Different cases require different professional perspectives.
Some instructions call for a detailed assessment of earning capacity and labour market opportunities. Others require specialist consideration of functional ability, visual impairment, accessibility or the practical demands of everyday life.
By recognising where these areas overlap, solicitors can identify the appropriate combination of expertise to address the issues in their case.
Thinking Beyond the Traditional Vocational Assessment
Vocational rehabilitation is about much more than returning someone to their previous job.
It is about understanding potential, recognising barriers, identifying realistic opportunities and helping ensure that important decisions about someone's future are informed by appropriate specialist evidence.
For solicitors, recognising where vocational expertise could contribute may uncover a valuable source of evidence in cases where it has traditionally been overlooked.
A parent caring for a child with complex health needs may have a very different realistic earning capacity from someone with identical qualifications but no caring responsibilities.
A neurodivergent professional who struggled in one working environment may have substantial earning potential in another, particularly where appropriate adjustments are available.
A person with a visual impairment may face significant barriers in one profession but be able to pursue other meaningful opportunities with accessible technology and specialist support.
And a young person with a life-changing injury may still have a wide range of future educational and professional possibilities that deserve to be properly explored.
The question is not always whether someone can return to work. Sometimes it is what their future could realistically look like — and what evidence is needed to establish that.
Discuss an Instruction
To discuss a potential instruction, confirm suitability or request further information about our specialists, contact Circle Case Management.
Email: expert@circlecm.com
Telephone: 01297 24145
Website: www.circlecasemanagement.com
Small enough to care. Large enough to cope.

